Wednesday, February 6, 2008

Catering to the Interests of the Students...

I had a really good class period today. Well, maybe I should re-phrase that: I had what felt like a good class period today, whether it was or not. For some reason, whether it be this strange bout of flu that is taking over the campus or just sheer laziness, only a little over half of my class showed up today, the day before their first drafts of the Critical Analysis is due. And I know that the Critical Analysis (along with the articles from The Presence of Others that they are supposed to be analyzing) is the least favorite of all papers they are doing this semester, but come on. So, as kind of a reward to the students that did show up (and to myself), I gave these students the option of writing a different kind of Critical Analysis: they could analyze a movie instead. Any movie would be fine as long as they actually analyzed it and didn't write a paper that just told me why they like this movie so much. The students really seemed to come alive (which I've found to be VERY rare for an 8:00 am class), and had all kinds of questions about how they could tackle this, as well as suggestions on how to approach watching their movie without bias so they could get an accurate analysis of it. It felt great to not have to give direction to the class, but to rather take a position more akin to a springboard for their ideas. And their excitement about doing this project also excited me for them (if that makes sense). I really enjoyed the class and felt like I might get some papers with a little more personality in them now.

1 comment:

smm933 said...

Your comments give me pause for reflection, Lee. My first reaction was that I would never allow my students to analyze a movie instead of an article. For one, I have always equated reading with writing. Two, I'm not a movie fan. There are very few movies I consider worth watching. Third - and this is what I stumbled on - is that I'm resisting technology as furiously as possible. I'm sure this is a by-product of my age, but do I do my students a disservice with this attitude? An example of this attitude was my initial reaction to the whole "blog" assignment - but now that I'm actually participating, it's not so bad. I'm intrigued by reading everyone else's posts - but then again, I always realized I was in the shadow of giants. Thanks for making me think.